Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
(570) 473-3563 Northumberland, PA

Google Reviews

Photo of Alison Difranks

Alison Difranks

Jennifer Phillips was the best insurance agent ever! She was so friendly and super informative! Learned things I didn’t even know like the kids trampoline needs to be insured 🤷‍♀️ But even after adding extra things like that still got a good deal. Thanks Jen!
Photo of Tim Phillips

Tim Phillips

Jen was able to tailor coverage for me with each policy. My protection and peace of mind increased while my premiums significantly decreased.
Photo of Sean Deiter

Sean Deiter

Great staff

Welcome to Keystone-Pfeiffer-Naginey Insurance

Happy Family

We are an Independent Insurance Agency, which means we have made available some of the best companies for your online quick quotes.     Learn More About Our Agency HERE 

We service the Northumberland, Selinsgrove, Lewisburg, Sunbury, Milton, PA. areas, and throughout the state of PA. At Keystone-Pfeiffer-Naginey Insurance each one of our clients are given a dedicated team of professionals that work together to proficiently address all your concerns.

We offer all types of Personal Insurance coverages to our clients in PA, including AutoHomeMotorcycleBoat & WatercraftFlood Insurance, and Life and Health Insurance.

Give one of our agents a call to save money on your business insurance. Some of our Commercial insurance coverages include Business Owners Packages (BOP), General Liability, Commercial Auto, Commercial Real Estate Insurance, and Contractors Insurance

Let us help you cut your insurance cost! Just give us a quick call today at 570-473-3563 or submit one of our quick online quote forms - with the help of our dedicated business partners; we conveniently offer an entire solution for all your personal and business insurance needs.

Why Our Agency is the Ideal Choice

Friendly Customer Service

Keystone-Pfeiffer-Naginey Insurance is renowned for treating clients like family with our genuinely friendly customer service. Our team excels in offering personalized, clear guidance, making insurance approachable. We prioritize understanding and addressing client needs with warmth and patience. 

Experience and Knowledge

The Keystone-Pfeiffer-Naginey Insurance in Northumberland, Selinsgrove, Lewisburg, Sunbury, Milton, PA. transforms your insurance journey with unmatched expertise and experience. Our dedicated team simplifies complex choices, ensuring personalized coverage that fits your unique needs, with the assurance of our long-standing industry knowledge and commitment to excellence. 

Securing the Best Rates

At Keystone-Pfeiffer-Naginey Insurance, we tirelessly shop for the most competitive insurance rates, ensuring you get the best value without compromising on coverage. Our relentless pursuit is to find optimal, customized solutions that align with your budget and needs, while delivering peace of mind.

Berkeley Mid Atlantic
Donegal Insurance
Guard Insurance Group
Liberty Mutual
Penn National