About Us - Keystone-Pfeiffer-Naginey Insurance

About Us

We’re excited to become your exclusive agent in selecting the insurance company best suited to fit your needs. With an endless supply of insurance companies and a myriad of coverages and costs, we are the single call you need to make to sort through the confusion. As an independent agent, we can quote many different insurance companies. We don’t “sell” insurance for any one company. And Keystone Insurers Group is the largest independent agency partnership in the country – Number One! Our size allows us to leverage competition to get our clients better coverage and better rates. Visit the Keystone National Home Page Here for our main national headquarters which is also located in Northumberland!

This is the peace of mind our busy clients have come to expect. They focus on their lives knowing we’re taking care of their insurance needs. When prices start to go up, our clients don’t have to go quote. They just give us a call and we do the work for them. Save yourself the hassle and confusion of searching the insurance market and make the one call, the only call, you need to make. Call Keystone Insurers Group, Pfeiffer-Naginey.

We’ve Got You Covered.We offer the following kinds of insurance plus unparalleled service throughout Northumberland, Selinsgrove, Sunbury, Lewisburg, Milton, Danville & Shamokin Dam.

Auto Insurance
Home Insurance
Health Insurance
Life Insurance
Business Insurance
Motorcycle Insurance
Medicare Supplements/Advantage

The experienced staff members here can outfit you with tailored solutions for your auto, home, and business insurance requirements and personalize each insurance product to your specific individual needs while providing competitive rates for all valued clients.

Agency Principal ~ Robert Naginey

Thank you for interest in our agency to handle your insurance needs. Everyone at Keystone-Pfeiffer-Naginey Insurance is dedicated to making sure that the insurance services we provide you are the very best available. As the agency owners, it is our mission to make sure you are a client of ours for a lifetime.

Jean Smith

President Keystone-Pfeiffer-Naginey Insurance. I am the senior-most tenured employee with Keystone having served at the agency since I first started working there at 20. I use that experience to help our commercial clients and to provide support and experience for our other service representatives and account managers.

Agency Principal ~ Thomas Troutman CIC, CWCA

Thank you for interest in our agency to handle your insurance needs. Everyone at Keystone-Pfeiffer-Naginey Insurance is dedicated to making sure that the insurance services we provide you are the very best available. As the agency owners, it is our mission to make sure you are a client of ours for a lifetime.

Agency Principal ~ Robin Straub CIC, CWCA

Thank you for interest in our agency to handle your insurance needs. Everyone at Keystone-Pfeiffer-Naginey Insurance is dedicated to making sure that the insurance services we provide you are the very best available. As the agency owners, it is our mission to make sure you are a client of ours for a lifetime.

Nathan Troutman CIC, CWCA, AAI

Hello, I am Nathan Troutman, CIC, CWCA, AAI; Commercial Insurance Agent with Keystone-Pfeiffer-Naginey Insurance. With the numerous components in a normal business insurance program, it's important to have an agent who understands the risks you face. Our clients enjoy the expertise and value of the long-standing relationships we provide. Plus, with access to multiple carriers, we are able to fit almost any business insurance need.

Sue Nice CIC

Hello, I am Sue Nice, HR & Accounting Coordinator at Keystone-Pfeiffer-Naginey Insurance. Whether your business is large or small, we can take care of all your insurance needs including property, liability, workers compensation and auto coverage. At Keystone, we offer numerous insurance companies and specialized programs.

Eddie Koebke CWCA

Commercial Insurance Agent
Hello, I am Eddie Koebke, Commercial Insurance Agent with Keystone-Pfeiffer-Naginey Insurance. My approach to insurance is buying as little insurance as you need, not as much as you can afford. To me, an insurance program should not be one size fits all because every client has different exposures. Instead, insurance should be customized to meet the needs of each client.

Bryant Klopp

Welcome, I am Bryant Klopp. I was raised in Northumberland and I’m a Shikellamy graduate. I’m happy to be back in this area after some time spent out of state and I'm excited to help our community with their insurance needs. Keystone-Pfeiffer-Naginey Insurance is a great company and being an independent agent, it gives us a lot of options to find the insurance carrier that works for you. Insurance is necessary, but it shouldn’t feel like a burden. Contact us so we can do your shopping for you and free you from your current carrier.

Jennifer Phillips

Hello, I am Jennifer Phillips. I was raised in Northumberland, PA and earned my bachelor’s degree in Social Work and Sociology from Muhlenberg College. I worked in Chicago and lived in Puerto Rico before PA called me back home. I have strong family connections in the area and a BFF named Napoleon – my cat. You’ll often find me exploring new local hot spots, living outdoor adventures and finding the best culinary experiences. I’m a dedicated listener and will make sure I find the right coverage for you, your loved ones and your most prized possessions – at the best prices in the marketplace!

Dane Snyder

Welcome, I'm Dane Snyder Vice President of the Home & Auto Division at Keystone-Pfeiffer-Naginey Insurance. I attended Slippery Rock University for my Bachelors and Masters degrees. I joined Keystone in September of 2014. I manage the Home & Auto division and specialize in farm and agribusiness insurance.

Colby Laudenslager CWCA

Hello, I am Colby Laudenslager, Vice President of New Business Development with Keystone - Pfeiffer Naginey Insurance. My approach to insurance is buying as little insurance as you need, not as much as you can afford. To me, an insurance program should not be one size fits all because every client has different exposures. Instead, insurance should be customized to meet the needs of each client.

Nate Weems

Hello, I am Nate Weems, the Individual Health, Medicare, and Life Insurance Specialist with Keystone-Pfeiffer-Naginey Insurance. Health Insurance, Medicare Plans and Life Insurance can be very complex and confusing, as there are endless options, companies and plans. As a licensed insurance agent, I have access to numerous reputable carriers and can do the shopping for you.

Robert Gill CWCA

Commercial Insurance Representative
Hello, I am Rob Gill, Commercial Insurance Agent with Keystone-Pfeiffer-Naginey Insurance. My approach to insurance is buying as little insurance as you need, not as much as you can afford. To me, an insurance program should not be one size fits all because every client has different exposures. Instead, insurance should be customized to meet the needs of each client.

Amie Savidge CISR

Hello, I am Amie Savidge, Commercial Insurance Agent at Keystone-Pfeiffer Naginey Insurance . I focus on new commercial clients with our agency. In addition, I help our existing commercial clients mange their worker's comp & find the most competitive pricing for their insurance needs.

Jessica Areford

Greetings, I'm Jessica Areford - the newest member of our team. I graduated from Lebanon Valley College earning my Bachelor degree. I work with new business clients quoting home and auto from the best companies and designing the best coverage for our clients.

Karen Keppler CISR

Hello, I am Karen Keppler, Commercial Account Manager with Keystone-Pfeiffer-Naginey Insurance. In addition to providing business insurance proposals, I help all of our commercial clients with changes to their policies, processing of claims and issues with billing.

Darla Markel CISR

Hello, I am Darla Markel, Commercial Insurance Customer Service Agent for Keystone-Pfeiffer-Naginey Insurance. In addition to providing business insurance proposals, I help all of our commercial clients with changes to their policies, processing claims and issues with billing.

Sandy Paul

Hello, I am Sandy Paul, a Commercial Insurance Customer Service Agent at Keystone-Pfeiffer-Naginey Insurance. I provide services to our clients including changes to their policies, claims, and billing questions. I am a graduate of Upper Dauphin Area High School. I have worked in the Commercial Insurance Industry for 13 years. I live in Elizabethville, PA

Vicki Long

Hello, I am Vicki Long, a Commercial Account Manager. In addition to providing business insurance proposals, I help all of our commercial clients with changes to their policies, processing of claims and issues with billing.

Dianne Troutman

Customer Service Rep ~ Home & Auto
Hello, I am Dianne Troutman a Customer Service Representative for Personal Insurance at Keystone-Pfeiffer-Naginey Insurance. Whether it's just a question about your policy or a new vehicle you need to add, I am here to provide you local, honest & understanding service. Insurance can be pretty complicated. But rest assured you always have someone on your side.

Ryan Mock

Hello I am Ryan Mock a commercial service rep and small business rater at Keystone-Pfeiffer-Naginey Insurance. I am a Susquehanna University River Hawk graduate and started working with the agency in January of 2016. I have already worked in just about every position in the agency. Currently I serve as the rater quoting coverage for home, auto & commercial insurance accounts. In my free time, I'm a big PSU fan and history buff.

Nicole Bossler

Receptionist
I am the first person you see and generally the first person you hear when you call. In addition to getting everyone to the right person, I provide assistance to both the commercial and personal home/auto departments processing payments & assisting with paperwork.

Tara Schueck CISR

Hello, I am Tara Schueck a Customer Service Representative for Personal Insurance at Keystone-Pfeiffer Naginey Insurance. Whether it's just a question about your policy or a new vehicle you need to add, I am here to provide you local, honest & understanding service. Insurance can be pretty complicated. But rest assured you always have someone on your side.

Michele Machamaer

Hello, I am Michelle Machamer a Customer Service Representative for Personal Insurance at Keystone Pfeiffer Naginey. Whether it's just a question about your policy or a new vehicle you need to add, I am here to provide you local, honest & understanding service. Insurance can be pretty complicated. But rest assured you always have someone on your side. I have three sons - including twins and spend plenty of time trying to keep track of those three boys! Previously I worked in the insurance industry handling home and auto insurance service for another agency.

Christy Lower

Hello I am Christy Lower Home & Auto / Commercial Insurance account manager in our small business unit. I really enjoy helping our commercial clients grow their businesses while keeping their hard work protected with the proper insurance. I stay pretty busy with 4 girls to drive to activities and games.

Lisa Acey

Greetings! My name is Lisa Acey, I am an Account Manager in our small business unit. When you own a business, you have a lot to protect, and the right small business insurance coverage can be important to your continued success. Acquiring the correct insurance coverage for your business needs can sometimes be intimidating. I am here to assist and guide you thru that process. I recently retired after a 25 year career with the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. I am married and have eight wonderful grandchildren, horses and hounds ! I am excited about my second career, and am here to serve you with the utmost reliability and integrity.

Brenda K Grace

In Loving Memory
Brenda K. Grace – 60 – Commercial Account Manager 1956 – 2017

It is with a heavy heart that the agency had to say goodbye to a great employee, friend & good spirit - Brenda Grace. Brenda spent 11 years with the agency and had been in the insurance industry for 43 years. She will be greatly missed by the clients she had served, her family and all of her colleagues here at Keystone. Our hearts and prayers are with her family and husband Steve.